When I made the impulsive decision to go back to church after two decades in the heathen wilderness, I bypassed the pews and headed straight for the choir loft. It was music, not religion, that brought me to First Presbyterian in downtown Beaufort almost eight years ago.
I grew up in Alabama, where my parents raised us Methodist. They sent my sisters and me to Sunday school, MYF, Camp Sumatanga, the works. Despite their diligence, it never really took. I stopped going to church in college at Sewanee, where I didn’t so much “lose my faith” as discover I didn’t have any. All it took was a little book learnin’—and a few late-night keg parties—and I was done getting up early on Sunday mornings for something that seemed both unlikely and irrelevant. Later, I went to grad school at the University of Alabama to study English. It was the late 1980s, deconstruction was all the rage, and the bias against religion was palpable in our department. To an insecure young scholar, the message came through loud and clear: you’re either a thinker or a believer; you can’t be both. I took that message to heart and lived it—rather religiously—for twenty years.
But I never got over the music. My parents had sung in the church choir; they’d brought us up to love Bach and Beethoven, Schubert and Handel. That stuff gets in your bones, your blood. Faith may desert you, but music doesn’t.
So there I was one cold morning in December, sitting in First Presbyterian Church of Beaufort—some friends had invited me—listening to the choir sing the Christmas part of Handel’s ‘Messiah’ . . . and crying like a baby. Something happened to me that morning, and I still don’t understand it. I heard the words I’d heard a thousand times before – And the government shall be upon his shoulder, and his name shall be called Wonderful Counselor, the Mighty God, the Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace— and my heart just cracked wide open. Suddenly, I wanted to believe those words more than anything in the world, and I wanted that music to go on forever. When the performance ended, I marched my shaken, trembling self up to the choir director—a total stranger—and asked if I could join his group. It was the most impetuous thing I’d ever done. Had I given it even a moment’s thought, I’d have talked myself out of it. I’ve since learned that Christians call this “stepping out on faith.” It felt more like walking the plank. I was terrified.
Fast-forward seven-plus years. I am a second soprano. I sit on the second row, near the middle of the choir loft, where I spend a lot of time studying the back of my minister’s head. Patrick is a youngish man—early forties—and I like the way his thick black hair swirls neatly above his collar. In summer, he wears an alb made of rough white cloth, with a fat rope at the waist. This monastic touch moves me, though I’m not sure why. I like hearing Patrick read scripture, his voice deep and resonant, without a trace of twang. I like that his sermons are thoughtful and challenging, that he quotes C.S. Lewis and Henri Nouwen, Martin Luther King and Bono. I sometimes wish he’d give easier answers—would tell me exactly what to be believe, and how—but I also know a preacher like that would soon drive me nuts . . . and right back out of the church.
It was in the choir loft that I shocked myself by remembering every single word of the Apostle’s Creed. It just came flooding back, line by line, after twenty years in mental exile. Same for the Lord’s Prayer, the Doxology, the Gloria Patri. I spent that first Sunday in the choir loft almost too overwrought to speak or sing. The words kept rushing back like long lost friends—who knew I’d missed them?—and my throat would tighten, then the tears would come. So I just listened, mostly; I’m not sure I’d ever really listened before. What splendid words they were! It felt so strange to be there, both audacious and humbling. (Who did I think I was, after all this time away?) But it felt right, too. Like coming home. I felt like the prodigal daughter.
From the choir loft, I can see everything—humanity in all its terrible beauty. Old men sleeping, young children squirming, teenagers snickering, new mothers joggling infants, rushing out when the wailing starts. I see women wobbling in on ridiculous heels and men checking their watches and kids doodling on their bulletins during the pastoral prayer. From the choir loft, everyone looks small and vulnerable and I love them all. Mercy comes easy in the choir loft.
Sometimes, after the prayer of confession, I can even extend it to myself.
I like watching the congregation walk forward to take Communion. The sight of all those ordinary people in their contemporary clothes slowly moving forward for this ancient sacrament just gets to me. People still do this. After 2,000 years. “Great is the mystery of faith,” reads the minister. I watch as the people pinch bread from the loaf, dip it in the cup, return to their pews, lower their heads. I wonder what they’re thinking, what they’re feeling. The body and blood of Christ. What does that mean to them? To me?
Presbyterians are big on their Scottish heritage, and from the choir loft the annual Kirkin’ of the Tartans is dazzling to behold. I’ll never forget my first Kirkin’ processional as it came toward me down the aisle—the men in their kilts and women in their sashes, the tartan flags held high, the mournful drone of bagpipes. When the service ended and the processional headed back toward the narthex, I caught sight of Rev. Miller and Bishop Hathaway from our neighbor church, St. Helena’s – the Bishop in full Anglican regalia, looking damn near papal—standing on the sidewalk outside our doors, waiting to parade with us through the streets of downtown Beaufort. The Anglicans were resplendent in the bright fall sunshine, and the image of them framed in our Presbyterian doorway is a permanent snapshot in my memory.
From my perch in the choir loft, it’s always wonderful to see our doors thrown open to the street outside. It happens every Easter, just before we end with the “Hallelujah Chorus.” The ushers open the doors, we choristers rise, the familiar strains of Handel’s joyous anthem begin, and the whole congregation stands. It’s taken me years of practice to sing over the lump that inevitably fills my throat. Handel brought me back to church, and Handel’s one reason I stick around. But not the only reason.
The possibility of getting Prostatitis resulting from Sexual inhibition Prostatitis is usually described as an inflammation of the pancreas that is referred to as biliary pancreatitis. cialis no prescription foea.org Your doctor would like to monitor your liver india cheapest tadalafil function while you are taking this medicine. If you are also thinking to take buy female viagra Kamagra as treatment for your erectile-problems: Never take the Kamagra pills in combination with the nitrate containing drugs and alpha brokers, it can lead to serious health complications. The ice therapy is very famous for reducing the blood flow in your viagra 25mg genital region.
It was in the choir loft that we sang “Holy, Holy, Holy” with all of Old Beaufort at Helen Harvey’s funeral. It was her favorite hymn—she adored the descant, and I swear there were angels singing it with us that day. It was from the choir loft that I heard Pat Conroy eulogize his dear friend and “second mother” Julia Randel, and there that I’ve sung the 23rd Psalm at more funerals than I can count. I’ve watched children weeping for their lost fathers from that choir loft, and mothers crying over their newly baptized babies, too.
Sometimes, I sit looking out at our sanctuary, so simple and austere (though I’m told there are more than twenty different shades of white paint in that room), and I miss the baroque church of my childhood—its dark, ornate carvings and flamboyant stained glass windows. I don’t know that I’m a Presbyterian at heart; I’m certainly not a Calvinist. If it were just about aesthetics, I’d probably be a High Church Catholic. If it were just about theology . . . well, who knows? I’m not sure it’s all that important. If God is Love, I’ve found Him here in this little white church in downtown Beaufort.
I still have all the old questions; I still struggle with belief. I probably make it a lot harder than it needs to be—once a thinker, always a thinker. But the choir loft is a very good place to hash it out. Or better yet, just to let it be. In the choir loft, I can rest with my questions. I can silence all those voices that vie for attention in my beleaguered brain—the critic, the cynic, the anxious preteen, the spoiled brat—and I can cultivate something akin to peace. Peace! And sometimes, if I don’t screw it up, I think I can even hear the voice of God.
And what it sounds like . . . is music.
Writer’s Note: I wrote this essay almost two years ago for a collection called State of the Heart: South Carolina Writers on the Places They Love, Volume 2, published by USC Press. The book is finally here and I couldn’t be more delighted!
October 19, 2015 at 2:37 pm
Thank you ever so much….
October 23, 2015 at 7:02 am
This is a wonderful article. Thank you. I live in Fort Mill, South Carolina. I became interested in Beaufort and began to read your paper online. I read several of your articles. The first one about the murders in a Charleston church. It was the best article I read on the subject which continues to wound my heart. I realized you are a Christina from reading the article. It is very refreshing to see a beautiful, talented and successful woman openly talk about the Lord. Thank you again.
November 8, 2015 at 2:26 pm
Right, gospel and spiritual music is uplifting and throat lumping, but the real deal is getting into scripture and tasting that it is sweet. And seeing how it lifts us up to Jesus and the joyful truth about our free salvation that was won for us by Christ on the cross and our faith that promises us an eternity in Heaven with Him.
I ran into a gal recently (at a bar! Oh come on, it’s ok!) and we found out that we were both Christians (yes, Jesus did have a few wines now and then, is that allright?). In the course of our talking about the Lord, she said something that so wrapped up the entire Christian theology in 4 short words that I’ll never forget it. Regarding all the many and various takes on what it takes to get saved, and be… and stay … a Christian, her words on that subject said it all. She said in response to that: “It’s Jesus plus nothing.” Huge exclamation point!
And I never fail to remember that one truth that stands out and above all others. Just thought I’d pass that on.
December 23, 2015 at 6:47 am
I liked your comment better than the others as you are spot on about how to be saved. Thanks for sharing that with this writer.
December 23, 2015 at 8:15 pm
Oh Rhoda, you have hit the nail on the head!
December 22, 2015 at 1:42 pm
I so enjoyed this article. And now I see why — assistant writer to Pat Conroy. I have read every book of his! And I always enjoy the SC settings. Thank you for sharing a portion of your faith journey.
December 22, 2015 at 4:05 pm
Thank you for the beautiful picture you have painted of your church. I miss so much the church I used to love and have yet to find a place of worship I feel comfortable or convicted about.
December 22, 2015 at 4:31 pm
As a church musician your article touched me deeply. I tried the Contact link but it didn’t work. May I have permission to reprint this article in our Westminster Presbyterian Church newsletter?
Thank you and Merry Christmas!
December 23, 2015 at 2:53 pm
Hi, Deborah. Thanks so much! Sorry about that contact link – not sure what’s going on there. I would be honored to have you preprint the essay in your church newsletter, as long as you mention that it first appeared in the book “State of the Heart: Vol 2” from USC Press. (They own the essay, and I had to do the same thing in order to publish it here on my blog.) Thank you! Margaret
December 22, 2015 at 6:12 pm
Beautifully written. I believe that there are a lot of us choir members out there who feel as you do. I have never felt closer to the Lord than I do in song.
December 22, 2015 at 8:19 pm
God’s Word creates faith in us. Sacred choral music uses scripture. I grew up in the choir loft and God’s word was hidden in my heart and I didn’t know it. When I wandered away from the church, that hidden word in the choral music brought me back. And it is all about Jesus plus nothing. He did everything for me. “It is finished! ” he cried with a loud voice from the cross. And we praise him with our music which says back to him what he has said to us. And that, my sister in Christ, is true worship.
December 22, 2015 at 9:52 pm
love, love, LOVE! thank you!
December 23, 2015 at 12:34 am
“Handel brought me back to church, and Handel’s one reason I stick around. But not the only reason.”
This is my story you have written, though I suspect I’m a good deal older than you. We are spiritual sisters. Indeed, the voice of God is music. Thank you.
December 23, 2015 at 12:43 am
Such a beautifully written tribute to your faith I too am a long time choir mrmber-infact that is where as a relatively young widow God found me my soulmate of now some 15yrs. we have been singing there ever since. The music of the church always moves me. Thank you for your article
December 23, 2015 at 2:06 am
I really enjoyed this article. It really reminds me of myself. I too went through something like this. But I Am glad I found the same kind of Love you found at your church. God is Good and He will lead us to the right place where we can Serve HIM….Love you in Jesus…Deantin Guerra
|
December 23, 2015 at 2:41 am
I read yout article tonight and my love for church music made me realize how important this music is. We are losing so much in our churches with the movements to modern so called music. The youth in our churches of today know nothing of the great music we love. I have never doubted my belief in Jesus plus nothing more, but the music you speak of brings me to tears of joy. Thank you for your articles.
remembering my country church
December 23, 2015 at 4:39 am
I understand completely the Prodigal Daughter’s story. I have sung in choirs – in three wonderful churches – for over 60 years and it has always been a deeply worshipful and moving experience. The message of the hymns and anthems along with the beautiful music always brings me closer to God than any other experience on this earth! I know these emotions show in my facial expressions because over the years so many people have told me they can see this. I know the time will come in this life when I am unable to express my feelings and emotions through the channel of Christian music, but I firmly believe I will be singing throughout Eternity in a Heavenly Choir!
December 30, 2015 at 11:18 pm
It’s been 66 years since I first sang in a church choir. I have had a number of forced relocations. Church choirs are small Christian communities that act like home – when you show up they take you in. The new pastor at the church I sing at now fired the choir director. The person chosen by the search committee said no. There was no plan B so we have an interim director. We sing in spite of the pastor and for the glory of God – sometimes in that order. If it were not for bureaucrats I might not believe in the devil.
December 23, 2015 at 7:49 am
Your essay showed up tonight and I wanted to thank you for writing it . I live in AL where I attend Anglican services in the chapel of First United Methodist Church in Dothan. Although I can’t really carry a tune, I think I understand everything you wrote. I look forward to reading more of your writings. Two of my favorite Christian writers are C. S. Lewis and Catherine Marshall, whose A MAN CALLED PETER and MR. JONES MEET THE MASTER touched me in junior high. BTW, my website is not ready but I hope to finish after Christmas.
December 23, 2015 at 11:38 am
Thank you for your words. I have been in a choir since I was a child. About 6 years ago I had a “life-changing” event in my life. I was a staff member at a Lutheran Church, over 33 years. I resigned from my position– leaving everything I loved. Our Church was split and I could not be a part of the new philosophy of judgment and hypocrisy. I went to another Lutheran Church, but I was really hurting. I cried during each worship service. I finally got the courage to join the choir . Needless to say, I became a part of the most loving support group I could have asked for. Music heals us, bonds us and helps us worship and give back. I am so thankful that you found your way back, I am sure your parents are very thankful as well.
December 23, 2015 at 12:12 pm
Thank you SO much for your heart-felt article!! I am a middle school choral director as well as the Director of Music and
Worship Arts at Clarkesville United Methodist Church. Your article has captured everything that I feel about “being in the choir”! I am also a people watcher and love watching the faces of our congregation every Sunday. One of the most holy times I have felt was the first time I assisted with delivering communion at the rail. As I served the bread and repeated the words “the body of Christ broken for you”, I was so overwhelmed with emotion! Again, thank you for sharing your heart!
December 23, 2015 at 12:31 pm
A fellow choir member found your article and sent it to all our choir at St. Paul’s Episcopal church in Athens, Tennessee. It touched me particularly because I am that person who spent forty years as a “thinker, not a believer.” I still think and I still doubt, but I am there for every practice and for every service. I love the choir. I love the choir members. What you say is true: “faith may desert you, but music doesn’t.”
December 23, 2015 at 1:02 pm
You told my story!
December 23, 2015 at 3:28 pm
What a lovely article. Pay no attention to these self-centered pietists who want to satisfy themselves that you’re believing and thinking exactly what they think you need to believe and think. Let the voices of the saints draw you nearer to the mystery that is God, let them speak and sing to you across the centuries, and as you join your voice with theirs, float upon that great sea of faith, sailing onward till you’re welcomed Home. Maybe today you believe it all, maybe tomorrow you don’t, but ruminations about the Invisible pale to just trusting that God has done what is needful to bring you to “him”self. And know that, as you’re singing at church, something is happening that can’t happen anywhere else? And what is that? It’s not just worship. You can worship in your car, in your living room, whatever. It’s not just praise, that can happen anywhere. Same with prayer, etc. No, what happens is that you are doing what was done for you that morning you speak of. You are bringing the “voice” of God into time and space again, not just the words on the page of a Bible, but the whole thing, the whole sensory experience, for it is THAT, of which the Scriptures are but one part, which blesses, renews, witnesses, and communicates the boundless, limitless, inexhaustible merits of the life and death of Jesus, and the love and mercy of God to a world sorely in need of it.
December 23, 2015 at 3:45 pm
Thank you, thank you, thank you.
December 27, 2015 at 2:38 am
Clint, such wonderfully encouraging thoughts written with such power and beauty makes me hope your position in life allows you to routinely share your gift and faith with as many as possible. I consider myself blessed to have access to Margaret’s musings. Your light is also bright and prismatic. Thank you.
December 23, 2015 at 4:35 pm
This is a lovely a peace-centred article that should resonate with people for whom theology, belief, and faith are not constants and not always synonymous with church going (as well as a good recruiting article for choir directors).
For me, being a Christian is about very simple, often ambiguous statements of faith, but the particulars of church – i.e. denominations – are more about preference, tradition, and family. Like the author of this article, I also sit in the choir loft, though I wish our particular Presbyterian parish were as in-touch with their Scottish heritage as the one in this article — but never-mind, because I bring that, myself, and I dutifully wear my kilt on reformation Sundays, explaining to the perplexed that, yes, our church does have Scotland to thank for its connection to the reformation.
I appreciate that she mentions her pastor not telling her exactly what to believe. “A certain comfort with ambiguity,” is something I value about Presbyterianism. One thing that I do think is required for a church to be welcoming and in fact useful, is for pastors and elders to not feel pressured to have answers to all questions; to invite people to search out God on their own and use the church as a resource; this includes coming to a personal definition of who/what God is and the role of scripture. In my experience, the pastors who answer questions with questions are more humble, more thoughtful, and more *pastoral* than those who answer every question with a memorised bible verse.
Being in the choir loft affords a person a shifted perspective on church going. You see that things aren’t perfect. You see the mess of microphone cables and jumbled miscellany hidden behind the pulpit and chancel walls. As parents, we trust a variety of people in the general congregation to keep an eye on our boy. In the choir, you realise that being able to sing well, or know much about music at all, isn’t necessary — just willingness to show up and make an attempt is all that’s really required.
Being in the choir is one avenue by which a person has a purpose for going to church that’s more than just showing up, sitting, standing, sitting, standing, and trying against all odds to remember what the pastor said or what the scripture was for the day (especially if it was off the prescribed lectionary).
For those of us for whom music is a primary medium through which we experience the presence of deity, or who just appreciate the simple beauty of the interactions of harmonic ratios in audible vibrations, it’s essential. I’m not always as enthusiastic about singing as I am about playing guitar, but it has allowed me to be musically involved every week, and the occasions for which I *do* get to play guitar are that much more special (and a welcome excuse to skip the choir robe). Though my particular beliefs, ideas, and opinions on theology are surely heretical to a stricter brand of believer, the choir is the place where we, believers of varying degrees, can meet on the level.
December 23, 2015 at 5:02 pm
What a wonderful comment. Thanks, Samuel.
December 23, 2015 at 7:18 pm
I believe God created music and gave us the ability to express it. There are many hymns that make me tear up every time I hear them, but “How Great Thou Art” is the one that digs deepest into my heart — whether I am hearing it or singing it. Right now, I do not attend a church and the truth is, I was not ready until recently. I was saved as a teen and although I spent years trying to put Him behind, Christ stayed with me, tugging at my soul and reminding me that I was not living for Him in the way that I was meant to do. It was music that finally dragged me back. Although I am not sure about WHICH interpretation of scriptures or any specific doctrine, I feel the way you do about songs of praise. God is love and every time we show real love, we please Him. Thank you for the reprint to let us all feel and enjoy. By the way, I learned about sex from Judy Blume, too. 😉 When I had children and they reached puberty, I insisted they read Are you there God, it’s me, Margaret and also But Then Again, Maybe I Won’t – both of them for my daughters and my son. Then I told them that if they wanted to ask questions or discuss anything, they could come to me. I would have sent this last tidbit to you from your contact page, but alas, I could not find an email. Blessings!
December 23, 2015 at 7:39 pm
Such a beautiful piece. I, too love my church. I still get goosebumps every time I attend.
God bless!
December 23, 2015 at 7:49 pm
This is beautiful. Thank you so much. Music is a big part of church experience for me, too. I also grew up Methodist … stayed with it. Love it.
December 23, 2015 at 9:20 pm
I have been a part of more churches and denominations than I can remember. And music has kept me going and encouraged me to be faithful. Your words reenforce this faith and the music helps me remember who loves me and why I sing in the choir. I cannot see the people in the congregation (because I am blind). But I have experienced love from my fellow choir members by people taking me to church for services and rehearsals, people sending the words for the music we sing, and someone knitting a hat that went with my choir robe when I lost my hair due to chemotherapy and so many people in the choir rand the congregation praying for me and rejoicing with me when I recovered. There’s a song that says all gods children got a place in the choir some sing low and sometsing higher some sing on the telephone wire and some just clap their hands or paws or handst or hing they got and that’s the way I feel about my cThoir and my church and how much they care for me and how grateful I am to be a part of them
December 24, 2015 at 3:59 am
Thank you for this essay. I love the music of our church, First Methodist. It has always meant so much to me over the years. What was so reassuring about your article was that I too had the same pattern. I grew up in a small town and attended a really small country church that was disbanded b/c the numbers dropped down to 25 people. We then attended the big church in town. I had perfect attendance for all the years until I graduated high school. At college, I joined the campus ministry. I played in the band, took piano lessons and was in the youth choir at school and church. So music has always been a large part of my life. After college, I drifted away from the church for many years and really did not return until we had two daughters. I knew that I wanted them to have a strong base of religious upbringing. Now when I attend church, I enjoy the music more than anything and find the music so uplifting and fulfilling. I have always felt a tiny bit guilty about liking the music better than anything at church but hey, they will just have to live with that. That is what I meant by saying I felt so much like you and what you wrote in this article. I have always felt validated when someone else has the same feelings and responses to something. For this, I thank you. I actually do not think I am a good singer so I have never joined our choir.
I really love the music at church b/c we have a wonderful choir director, organist and pianist. A lot of times, many other instruments are added to the mix. They present a Christmas cantata and a Patriotic service in July where the choir sings the entire service. I try very hard not to miss those days. A friend who attended the same church, had the same piano teacher and was in the band posted your article. I told her I was so glad she had done so. Merry Christmas and have many more years singing the praises of our Lord.
December 24, 2015 at 5:22 am
Thank you so much for sharing. I lived for many years without the joy of singing in a choir. Now that most of my working time is over I found choral music again and it brings much into my life.
December 24, 2015 at 3:59 pm
Wow! I cried the entire time I read this out loud to my wife. The most profound thing I’ve read in quite some time. You touched my heart and I thank you. Soli Deo Gloria!
December 24, 2015 at 5:09 pm
Lovely… and so my heart sings.
Thank you.
December 24, 2015 at 5:31 pm
As a soprano who has been sitting in choir loft sine age 9, you have absolutely captured what keeps me there. Thank you so much!
December 25, 2015 at 7:19 am
It’s Christmas day and we again celebrate the birth of our Lord and savior Jesus the Chrisr. Can we “do Christmas” without the music of the season? I’ve been in a choir, directed both a church and middle school choir and have seen first-hand the joy of singing our faith. Thanks for your message of faith and teetering. I think we’re all been there! Handel didn’t write in a vacuum — he had a wonderful ghost (-ly) writer leading him on and helping him pick the words from the scriptures that make us know who I AM is. There can be no doubt — except now and then. Look back towards your United Methodism background for the OK to think for yourself and to question. Does that make any sense at all? Love to you and yours on this most joyous day.
December 25, 2015 at 9:35 pm
Beautiful essay, Margaret. I wonder also if we ever figure it all out in terms of holding fast to our faith in God. There is nothing like music to pierce our hearts with the miraculous presence of God . I believe that music is a special blessing for us all. Thank you for capturing this so beautifully.
December 26, 2015 at 3:44 am
You feel like my sister, although I still struggle to find where I might fit in. Thank you for expressing the loss and the finding so well.
December 26, 2015 at 4:12 pm
My choir director recommended this article as a “must read”, and I am truly connected to and touch deeply be your words. My mother also came back to church because of music. It was the music of the Christmas season that she missed, and it was that same music that re-rooted her into the fellowship of other Christ followers. She now has a prominent place in “the loft”, as do I, be it though we are six hundred miles apart. I might not have come back to the church for the music as much as the need of my soul to be fed, but I have since then been in the same vantage point as yourself, to see the ones with tears in their eyes as the “music” touches their hearts, as the Spirit uses what we, as singers, do with joyful service. I see the hurt from the loft and use it as a means of list making, to make sure I can speak love to the ones who seem to need it the most that day. Mostly, I am glad I made it through another service without that proverbial lump messing up a solo, without my own tears bringing notice to my own pain being ministered to. I once asked the Father, why is it I get so choked up at times during worship. He responded in my heart that, just as a child of a deployed parent, who longs so deeply to be back in their arms, cries at the sight of their return, we too, as His children, long deeply for His presence. They don’t cry from sadness, but out of being “Overjoyed”. To cry is the deepest emotion we have, and we do it when we become very angry, very sad and also Overjoyed. Once He moves into and abides in the praises of His people, we become overjoyed at our deepest level and cry. Your peace here has moved me today and reminded me of how precious a gift it is, for us who do, to be able to serve Him in the loft. Blessings to you and Thank you very much!
December 27, 2015 at 10:18 am
Thank you. I love love love southern gospel, I haven’t been inside a church in a long time, but at random times, the shower, trolley or in bed, the great ones, Amazing Grace, Old Rugged Cross, How Great Thou Art, Because He Lives, Victory In Jesus , they all come back, every line and every verse. For a brief time I’m taken back to the time where I believed and faith wasn’t something to think about, it just was. I feel a part of me is empty, but then Todays current Hits, Trap and Pop are soon blasting through the speakers again, the voices of the past are once again gone and life is just an endless cycle of emptiness with no light at the end of the tunnel
December 28, 2015 at 2:05 am
WOW! What a marvelous testimony to faith and practice! God bless music! God bless the Presbyterians! God bless the choir director for welcoming acceptance. I was raised a Methodist, educated in a Presbyterian Seminary; I don’t know where I would be if it hadn’t been for church music!
December 28, 2015 at 2:54 am
I am a son of Alabama, matriculated at Sewanee in 1979 (although I didn’t finish what I started, much to my later chagrine), and lost my music along the way. Perhaps you’ve helped me find it. Thanks. Here’s to you!
December 28, 2015 at 4:38 pm
I understand your still being a “thinker.”Actually you can be both a thinker and a believer but you have to get out of the normal “Church”
mode and dig a little deeper into the faith. I would suggest you check out another Presbyterian, Gary DeMar’s, works. They will give you plenty of thinking fodder as well as answer some of the questions you may have about why normal church has often become stale. By the way I do believe that God’s voice must sound like music.
December 28, 2015 at 6:09 pm
Yes. A deep, unequivocal yes. Thank you.
December 30, 2015 at 11:36 pm
I started singing in choir 66 years ago. I have had to relocate multiple times over the years. Choir is a small Christian community that functions like home – when you show up they take you in,
July 1, 2019 at 5:39 am
Slow to rebel, young Margaret finally flees the world of manners and custom—which she deems poor substitutes for right thought and right action in the face of the Civil Rights movement and the Vietnam War—and abandons her fundamentalist upbringing. In a defiant gesture that proves prophetic, she once signed a postcard home The Prodigal. After years of being the distant, absent daughter, she finds herself returning home to meet the needs of her stroke-crippled younger sister and her incapacitated parents.
November 4, 2019 at 3:11 am
I heard you read part of this post this evening at the Conroy Festival’s “State of the Heart” and had to come back and read it all. Wonderful, even if I am probably more of a Calvinist, but then my faith grew under a gracious agonistic philosophy professor in college… Would it be okay if I link to this in one of my email newsletters where I highlight readings I have found meaningful?
November 4, 2019 at 11:56 am
Absolutely, Jeff. I would be honored if you did. Thanks so much for attending our “State of the Heart” panel. It was a pleasure to be part of it!