I almost didn’t write this piece. In doing so, I willfully open myself up to the harsh disapproval and flat-out wrath of many whom I respect and admire. That knowledge gives me no pleasure and, in fact, makes me shudder. But these thoughts – to use a once-lovely phrase I’ve grown to loathe – have been “on my heart” for a while, and I won’t rest until I’ve aired them.
Many of you know I recently spent a week cruising the Caribbean with my mom. What most of you don’t know is that we were traveling with a group of thinkers and writers and readers of National Review magazine. Yes, that National Review. America’s foremost journal of conservative thought. Brainchild of the late William F. Buckley, Jr.
My parents are conservatives. Serious, thoughtful, principled conservatives. They have been reading National Review for decades and cruising with NR annually for almost ten years. My dad has some health issues and is no longer able to travel comfortably, so for the past two cruises, I’ve gone as my mom’s companion. And you know what? I’ve loved every minute of it. Spending a week with brilliant, funny, friendly intellectuals who relish ideas and rollicking debate is my idea of a damn fine vacation. What can I say? Some people like gambling. Others like lounging by the pool, playing shuffleboard, or shopping. I like a good mental workout.
As I write this, I resent the fact that I have to worry about doing so. I resent the fact that American politics has become so grotesque and fraught that I’m forced to choose between telling the truth and maintaining your respect – that I can’t do both. Most of all, I resent the fact that I’m such a freaking wuss… that I lack the courage and boldness that should be a writer’s very lifeblood… that I care too much about being liked and not enough about being honest. I tried writing political columns years ago, when I first started to suspect that my parents had passed along more through their genes than just blue eyes and a prominent nose. When I finally stopped buying into the left’s definition of the right – the only definition I’d ever paid attention to – and discovered what conservatives really think, by reading their own words, it was like a veil had been lifted, and I wanted everybody else to see the light, too!
I learned the hard way that people don’t like having their veils lifted. They prefer to lift their own veils… or not. Sudden, unexpected light can hurt your eyes. It can even blind you. And then you’re worse off than you were with the veil.
Yes… it was an ugly time. Far from showing people the light, I brought an extended period of darkness upon myself. Looking back, it was mostly my own fault. My delivery was off. In my newfound “wisdom,” I was condescending and snarky and too clever by half. I was attempting a giant eye roll at my former, know-nothing self, but it came across as an eye roll at my readers. Also, I overcorrected in a big way. So thrilled was I with this revelation about conservatism (“It’s not what I thought!”) that I plunged from left to right like a giddy preteen dumping Bieber for One Direction, briefly forgetting that I am, in my heart of hearts, a deeply moderate person. I regret the whole unfortunate period, have settled down happily in the middle – where I belong – and have put political writing behind me, for the most part.
But what I haven’t put behind me is my aching, fervent wish that the two sides of our political divide understood each other better, so we could have a real, rousing, and possibly even productive conversation. Without tearing each other to bits. While on the cruise last week, I kept wishing my liberal husband and all my liberal friends were there, so they could see what thinking conservatives are really like . . . and hear what they really care about. I contend that the “divide” is less about disagreement than about different priorities. And super-smart people are just fun to hang out with, whatever their politics! You guys would have liked each other.
I recently watched a show on anxiety that was aired on TV viagra pill price that I got from one of the Dish TV Offers. Diet and Impotence Condition Impotence issue is caused due to many factors, hence physicians recommend ED patients to avail a high quality treatment. cheap viagra pills Talk to Your Doctor An important step if you are experiencing signs cialis online cheap of ED condition, make sure that you talk to a health care provider immediately. Standard drug makers make generic best price for tadalafil version of every drug so that people can buy generic drugs and save money while taking quality medicine.
One of the NR writers on board was Charles C.W. Cooke, a dashing young Brit who is more learned, at age 30, than most of us will ever be, and who writes like an absolute dream. Charlie’s got a book coming out in early 2015 called The Conservatarian Manifesto, and he brought along the introduction for us cruisers to read and ponder. In it, he laments the misconceptions people have about conservatives and seeks to correct them. If you truly want to know what American conservatives think, this is a great primer. (Hint: It has nothing to do with racism.) For best effect, read with a charming British accent.
“That in America, the friends of liberty are called ‘conservatives’ and the centralizing authoritarians are referred to as ‘liberals’ is one of the great semantic jokes of history. In almost every other part of the world, rightward-leaning political movements seek primarily to conserve the long established order, and in consequence compete not for meaningful ideological terrain but for stewardship and for stasis. Elections abroad tend to be narrow and meretricious affairs, in which minor reductions in the considerable power of the state take on great significance and ‘philosophy’ is seen as a dirty, even dangerous, word.
“In the United States, by happy contrast, conservatism is marked by its unorthodoxy and its radicalism. Conservatives are passionate and ambitious, and their concern is for neither the international norms nor the tribal precepts that have animated most of human history, but for the manifestation of eccentric ideas that have surfaced only recently– among them property rights; separation of powers; hard limits on the power of the state; staunch protections on the rights of conscience, assembly, speech, privacy, and self-protection; a preference for local governance over central planning; a free and dynamic market economy that permits rapid change and remarkable innovation; and, above all, a distrust of any government that would step in to answer questions that can be better resolved by civil society.”
Now, does that really sound so bad? My mom was in tears when she read this statement of her long-held beliefs and values. In a world where the media have almost completely (albeit erroneously) succeeded in equating “conservative” with “ignorant,” “hateful,” and “bigoted,” these eloquent articles of faith fell like manna from heaven on my highly educated and accomplished mother. Over the years, this gracious woman has grown far too accustomed to being misunderstood and maligned for her politics.
And, oh, how I resent that.
Listen. You don’t have to endorse these conservative values, dear reader. You may peruse the list above and disagree with every tenet… think it’s all poppycock. That’s fine with me. As I said, I’ve settled into a moderate position, politically speaking. I think both sides have good ideas (and bad ones) and important priorities, and that it’s mostly a matter of balance. (True believers on both sides will disagree with me here, and that’s okay, too.) All I ask of you, reader, is this: Please, please expand your political imagination. Dare to impute good intentions to your political opponents. Treat them with the humanity they deserve. Do not assume that “misguided” means “evil.” Dare to imagine that, sometimes, you might even be the one who’s misguided. And always remember – your political foe is probably somebody’s mother.
And next time you find yourself buying into the tired stereotype of conservatives as stodgy, old, ignorant racists desperately clinging to the status quo, reread Charlie Cooke’s manifesto above, and remember this awesome selfie of me with NR libertarian bad-boy Kevin Williamson. Dude’s a mad genius. He even has tattoos.
November 19, 2014 at 7:40 pm
Outstanding as usual.
November 19, 2014 at 7:45 pm
I always knew you were a remarkably brave and brilliant person, and now you have just proved it. Again.
November 19, 2014 at 8:18 pm
Margaret, there will never be a problem in engaging in dialogue across ideological lines as long as the askers really wish to know and the tellers can stand by and defend without rancor what they are saying. As Socrates put it plainly: the appropriate penalty for being mistaken is instruction from the wise. The best way to get past the blanket dismissal of nominal Conservatives–a category that includes both Ted Cruz and Edmund Burke–is to refuse to use or even acknowledge the label and instead address only the substance of what is being said, which you seem admirably willing to do.
November 19, 2014 at 11:54 pm
Brilliant and beautiful! I had much the same experience when I read C.S. Lewis for the first time. My, my! Was the veil ever lifted.
November 20, 2014 at 12:05 am
Sarah, I feel the same exact way about Lewis! Nobody has influenced my thinking more than he has…
November 20, 2014 at 1:00 am
If you come to visit me in Louisiana, I’ll make you a bourbon drink and we can stand outside in bare feet in the drainage ditch after it rains. It’s not a NR cruise, but it’s what I got, cher.
November 20, 2014 at 1:47 am
Rod, I would love to drink bourbon with you in a drainage ditch any time. (I’m gonna make it to that Walker Percy weekend one of these days…)
November 20, 2014 at 4:06 am
Thank you Margaret! Unlike you, I was born and raised in a Democrat family that still thinks conservatives are the devil incarnate. It wasn’t until I started to REALLY LISTEN to a different point of view and think for myself, that my veil was lifted and I saw that brilliant light. In the words of a very wise man I know, “I prefer CLARITY to agreement” on the crucial issues we are facing in today’s world. Thank you for providing such a clarifying article.
November 20, 2014 at 7:09 am
This was brilliant. Well done!
November 20, 2014 at 9:42 am
You had me at the pic with Kevin Williamson. I love crazy smart ! Great thoughts on true conservatism!
November 20, 2014 at 12:41 pm
Thank you. I love a good discussion and the ability to hear without agreeing. What a breath of much needed cerebral oxygen!
November 20, 2014 at 8:23 pm
I’m not sure why you would feel such trepidation in voicing these comments. As a strong Progressive, I find nothing offensive here in the least. I think it can only help our chances for dialog if true conservative thought is better represented because, you’re right, most of what a Progressive sees and hears about “the conservative movement” isn’t pretty. I enjoyed reading this piece, but I did shudder at the thought of mistakenly booking a cruise only to find out it’s me, three other clueless people, and 600 National Review groupies…
November 20, 2014 at 8:38 pm
Bruce, thanks for your response. I believe you’re the only strong Progressive who’s weighed in. This thing has gone pretty viral (for me, anyway), and I’ve heard from lots of moderates and conservatives, but no progressives. I appreciate it! And don’t worry… the scenario you describe would be very unlikely. We were on a ginormous ship that had something like 6,000 people on it. We were only about 500. You could have easily spent the whole week never encountering a single NR person. And if you did, you might not have known it. They blend in very nicely. 😉
November 20, 2014 at 9:35 pm
Loved your piece! Wonderful, as always. These are confusing times for people like me. If I am staunchly conservative in some ways and quite liberal in others, does that make me a “Moderate”, a word which has become almost as much a “dirty word” as “Liberal” has? I don’t suppose it matters really, because whenever the party politics gauntlet is flopped down onto the social killing floor I get in trouble anyway. I don’t fit any particular template, so my opinion doesn’t count. Conservatives dislike me for it and so do Liberals. It’s akin to what happens when people find I support both Bama and Auburn until the Iron Bowl game, then I get off the fence. We only get respect in the black and white world. I think it’s a shame.
November 20, 2014 at 10:46 pm
Did they happen to mention how Wall St/Corporate greed “can be better resolved by civil society.”
November 21, 2014 at 7:30 am
Sorry….but sounds like the “veil” has been easily dropped again. I understand. I was raised Southern Baptist and my mother, just as recently as yesterday, sent me a email regarding the “war on Christmas.” Of course, there is no such thing. Why are conservatives the ones who always seem to be the knee-jerks to everything? And why are they the ones who are so obviously trying to remove the right to vote? Please…..explain. Show me proof of conservative, or “moderate” action to preserve the right to vote by everyone without gerrymandering or downright voter intimidation??
It is difficult to grow out of what has been forced into you from birth. And I am all for freedom of thought. But this piece sounds like being with these “brilliant” people helped lift this “veil” and awakened you to a line of logic that you were already raised in. And that is very easy to fall back into. I’ve no ill will towards my parents. Obviously! But they continue to snowball down this old, irrelevant hill of some sort of “good ole days” which were never reality.
This Charles C.W. Cooke is not some great awakening. I’ve heard him go on about the greatness of Margaret Thatcher….not to mention Reagan (and calling President Obama “imperial”). That should say it all. And I’m very familiar with his twisted, nut job “analyses” of the African-American experience in this country (and I said that with a British accent). Though, I would agree that, in comparison, Reagan is a MUCH better choice than what the Republican party is today.
Anyway, I’m glad for the quality time with your parents, and particularly your mom.
Tim
PS. Tattoos are not an indicator of some sort of rebellious, progressive philosophy. In fact, all indicators point to the opposite.
November 21, 2014 at 10:51 am
Thanks for your comment, Tim. But actually, you DON’T “understand.” I didn’t grow up with any political foundation whatsoever. We didn’t talk politics at our house when I was a child. The most I remember hearing about it were statements like “I vote for the candidate, not the party.” I don’t think my parents even belonged to a party. They didn’t become avid conservatives until long after I’d left for college, then graduate school, where I became every bit as “progressive” as anybody else receiving a higher education in the humanities in the 1980s. It was the very air we breathed, and that air filled my lungs for some 20 years afterwards, so any “veil lifting” would have had to come from the other direction.
I never said, nor meant to imply, that Charles Cooke is a “great awakening” – just an intelligent young man who eloquently articulated some American first principles that seem to have been forgotten in all the noise of our brash political scene. Nor did I suggest that Kevin Williamson’s tattoos mean he has a “progressive” philosophy. Far from it (as “progressive” is defined today, anyway). Is his a “rebellious” philosophy? I think Libertarianism is fairly rebellious, especially considering Libertarians, because of their association with the GOP, have to contend with the tired, stale assumptions people like you make about them. I’m sorry about your mom, but MY mom never sends me silly emails about some fake “war on Christmas.” I doubt Kevin’s does, either. I only mentioned his tattoos (in a joking manner!) to point out that the conservative movement, despite what people who don’t know it THINK about it, is actually a big tent containing great philosophical and even demographic diversity.
I know I won’t convince you of that; your words and tone tell me your mind is made up and has been for a long time. That’s fine. Most people prefer being settled. I have a restless mind. Thanks for writing.
November 21, 2014 at 1:38 pm
Tim Tucker, your comment demonstrates exactly the bias that Margaret is addressing. The bias doesn’t upset me nearly as much as the fact that you appear to be blind to yours.
November 22, 2014 at 12:17 am
Margaret, that was so eloquent and you absolutely hit the nail on the head. It is perfectly okay to be moderate. I have many “liberal” views and I also have “conservative” views on some things. If we all could just stop berating each other over being one or another and start seeing things in shades of gray, people could easily have intelligent discussions across “party lines.” Like you parents, I vote for the people I like, not the party ticket. I envy you that opportunity to converse with people from all over with unique views of the world. I am so glad you did go and chose to write about it. You are no wuss for being moderate. If there was more moderation in our thoughts and deeds, the world would be a much better place. Kudos.
December 1, 2014 at 2:20 pm
“Dare to impute good intentions to your political opponents.”
That’s the crux of it.
Beautiful essay. I came here via Jay Nordlinger and will be coming back.
December 1, 2014 at 3:40 pm
Great piece, Margaret!
I hope at least a few left-of-center folks take your words to heart. I live in liberal Massachusetts and people here always look at me like I have two heads when I have the temerity to express an opinion that is contrary to their political orthodoxy. I’m amazed at how few are intellectually curious enough to read serious conservatives who might begin to challenge their beliefs.
Citizens in a republic have an obligation to respect and understand their adversaries. Your advice is wise.
December 1, 2014 at 4:16 pm
Margaret I think we had conversations about this with your mom at the schooner bar! Great read. I hope to see both your dad and your husband on the next cruise. If your husband doesn’t want to talk politics you know Bill and I can just talk football.
Charlie White
December 1, 2014 at 4:19 pm
Glad you are making progress! NR’s appreciation for limited government is inversely correlated to its support for anti-communistic militarism. Find and read Liberalism Revisited to understand the roots of modern liberalism. Then read Jonah’s book, Liberal Fascism, for an update. Have fun!
December 1, 2014 at 5:02 pm
So jealous of you! But with 3 kids in school NR cruises are out of reach for the next several years. For a good all round survey of classical liberal thought, check out Russell Kirk’s The Conservative Mind. By the way – Does Kevin know that he looks and sounds almost identical to Jamie Hyneman on Mythbusters!?
December 1, 2014 at 7:24 pm
Thanks to all you folks who came over from The Corner. (Seriously? I’m on The Corner?!) It’s great to have company and I encourage you all to take an NR cruise as soon as you can swing it. Good times with great people… (Joel, Kevin is much more handsome than Jamie Hyneman. 😉 )
December 1, 2014 at 10:05 pm
Margaret, I enjoyed your article
You really should read “The secret knowledge : on the dismantling of America culture”
by David Mamet
It might clear up some of the group think realities that keep the herd together on the left and made your transition so painful.
The comments from leftists (Bruce & Tim) clearly show the dismissive attitude to any conservative ideas or proposals. Leftists will talk about open debate and dialog but fear any contamination from the right.
I am a fiscal conservative and proud american, but an atheist and a supporter of gay marriage (but disdain for the extreme left gay agenda forced on christians et al who disagree). As an atheist (small A, non-practicing non-proselytizing atheist) I believe that religion and churches do great good in the world and are under attack from the Left.
December 2, 2014 at 12:19 am
Is there anything about the cruise that actually changed your mind about a specific policy, or any substantive issue facing the country? War, taxes, education, global warming, the role of government, gun control? Or was it enough to realize that some conservatives have tattoos and others can express a self serving definition of their ideology in a British accent to open your eyes. I’m not sure what the takeaway is, that conservatives can have fun and are not universally racist goobers or crotchety greed heads ? I could have told you that. (Some of my best drinking buddies are conservatives)That’s not the issue. The issue is what are the right ideas and policies for America? That didn’t seem to factor into your previous dismissal of conservatives and it doesn’t seem to factor much into your new found embrace of them. That said, you seem like a nice person and it’s always good to be reminded that good people exist all over the political spectrum.
December 2, 2014 at 11:29 am
Fielding Mellish, I wrote this short, personal piece for my blog, certainly never expecting to see it land on The Corner. As I said, I’m not a political columnist, and the piece isn’t about “specific policy” – though plenty of policy specifics were discussed on the cruise. I’m sorry if I made myself unclear, but I already knew that conservatives can “have fun” and are “not universally racist goobers or crotchety greed heads.” I’ve known for a long time that these are largely false stereotypes. Based on your comment (and despite the mention of your drinking buddies), I can’t tell if YOU know that or not. In my experience, many people do not. And THAT is what I chose to write about here – not policy ideas. As long as a large group of people who control the media, the academy, and much of the culture, insist on viewing/portraying conservatives as stupid and evil, there’s hardly any point in conservatives HAVING policy ideas… they won’t get a fair listen. I agree that politics should be about “ideas and policies,” but one side of the political spectrum always insists on making it personal. Why go to the trouble of understanding and addressing your opponent’s ideas when you can just cry “racist!” or “climate denier!” and end the conversation before it ever gets started?
December 4, 2015 at 2:27 am
I, too, am a Conservative. I’m one of those people who writes what I believe and don’t really care whether people like it or not. Unlike many Facebook participants, I express my thoughts and opinions by writing about them in detail. I try to at least comment on every article I post, as I don’t post any aticle unless it’s significant – and correct, at least to me. I have always realized that I will please all of the readers sometime, some of them most of the time, but never every reader all the time. So I don’t worry about that and just try my best to state my opinion or make my case. Quite often I post an opinion or an article with a comment and receive absolutely no Likes and no Comments. Sometimes I wonder whether anybody ever reads what I post. But I don’t really care. I’ve expresed my feelings and/or opinions, and that’s all that matters. I hope you, too, have finally arrived at a similar conclusion.
I wish you well. Thank you for writing this wonderful personal and honest piece. I enjoyed it very much.